Winter Soldier - The Sidekick who came in from the Cold War
(PART ONE)

 
When first introduced in the late 1930s and early 1940s, "sidekicks" were as much a plotting and marketing device as they were characters in a superhero comic book. Bill Finger, for example, found it increasingly difficult to write Batman stories with the hero stuck in thoughts or soliloquy, and so convinced Jerry Robinson and Bob Kane that the Darknight Detective needed someone he could talk to during his missions (Robb, 2014). When Robin the Boy Wonder made his first appearance in Detective Comics #38 in April 1940, he wasn't the first sidekick in comic book history, but by being a young kid (and later on a teenager) he hit home like no other - because Dick Grayson allowed young readers to relate to the stories in a way they had not been able to do so before. Not only did Batman now have someone to talk and explain his actions to (which immediately also made him a less dark and more accessible persona), but sales of Detective Comics almost doubled (Robb, 2014).

Not surprisingly, sidekicks became something of a must-have for superheroes, and Martin Goodman's business instincts dictated that over at Timely/Marvel the already launched Human Tourch be paired with a young equivalent named Toro in the autumn of 1940 in Human Torch Comics #2. And when Joe Simon and Jack Kirby came up with a patriotic superhero named Captain America (a consciously political creation), he was given his kid sidekick straight off the bat in Captain America Comics #1 (March 1941).

 
Readers were thus not only introduced to GI Steve Rogers (who lives a secret double life as super-soldier Captain America out of New Jersey’s Camp Lehigh) but also to one young Bucky Barnes, the "mascot of the regiment” - who inadvertently discovers Rogers' secret.

In the enlightened age of 1940s comic books, where hardly any questions regarding story coherence were ever raised and even fewer of them answered, Captain America simply swears in Bucky as his sidekick on the spot : "from now on we must both share this secret together ... that means you’re my partner, Bucky!"

And so Captain America and Bucky would spend the next few years battling Nazis, traitors and spy rings just the same way as Batman and Robin were taking out masked villains in Gotham City. Two sides of the same coin, it worked well until horror, cowboys became the flavour of the day. Batman hung on, but Captain America Comics ceased publication in 1949.

 


Captain America Comics #1 (March 1941)

 
The fights, it seemed, had all been fought and everybody had gone home - until something unexpected happened in 1963. Following a year of sensational success with superhero material, writer/editor Stan Lee and writer/artist Jack Kirby decided it was time to bring back Captain America and introduce him to the wonderous world of Marvel Comics.
 

Avengers #4 (March 1964)
  However, there was a problem: Stan Lee had always had a strong dislike for (young) sidekicks (Lee, 1974). He had also perfected the "identity anchor" with readers by making the teenager in the book the actual lead character - witness Peter Parker and Spider-Man. And by introducing Cap to the Avengers, there was more than one superhero character to talk to anyway. Stan Lee wanted Cap, but there simply was no way he was going to put up with Bucky.

And so, when Steve Rogers is brought back in Avengers #4 (March 1964), there is no Bucky - and Stan Lee does his very best to ensure there never will be, as readers learn from a flashback how during the last days of the war Bucky is blown up while trying to stop a booby-trapped plane in midair, whilst Cap tumbles into the frigid waters off Newfoundland below, where he ends up spending the next decades frozen in suspended animation. And then, as the Avengers witness a rescued Cap coming back to life and remembering that event, Stan Lee declares Bucky dead once and for all ("He is dead - he is! And nothing on Earth can change that!") but at the same time seizes upon the golden opportunity to turn Bucky into something every Marvel superhero must have: that typical "flaw" - a psychological chip on his shoulder, a personal tragedy which haunts the protagonist for ever.

 
From then on, bringing Cap's old sidekick back into stories any way other than as a lingering memory (with bad psychological effects on Steve Rogers) was strictly off limits at Marvel. Some even jokingly say there was a memo from Stan Lee hanging from the main office message board to that effect. If true, it may have faded or fallen off completely by the time the new millennium dawned, or maybe it was simply a new generation of creators who came to Marvel, who brought along their own ideas and really weren't into reading any old memos - because after having been dead and actually stayed dead for all of four decades, Bucky Barnes was finally brought back, in January 2005, in an epic comic book saga which launched volume 5 of Captain America.
 
However, it was a comeback with an almighty twist to it.

Writer Ed Brubaker, recruited in 2004 to relaunch Captain America, had very clear ideas about what he wanted to do with Marvel's iconic hero - and how this involved his long dead sidekick Bucky:

"My whole approach to the book centered around exploring Steve as a tragic character, carrying the weight of being Captain America (...) So as part of that tragedy, I wanted to bring back Bucky as a villain that would link Steve to his own past, give him a new tragedy to struggle with, and out of that, explore a different man out of time, Bucky Barnes, who had become something he would have hated." (Ed Brubaker in Slayton, 2014)

Brubaker would thus not take away the personal tragedy linking Steve Rogers with Bucky Barnes, but rather change and tweak it. And this time around it would be even worse for Cap to bear.

Taking the few panels from Avengers #4, Brubaker didn't actually change the chain of events of Stan Lee's storyline but rather told readers that all this time the concluding assumption that Bucky had died was simply wrong.

What actually happened, readers now learn, is that the explosion rips off Bucky's left arm and causes him to suffer total amnesia, but he too survives and falls into the same icy waters. But unlike Cap, who will spend the next two decades frozen in suspended animation, Bucky is rescued by a Russian secret service officer who hands him over to the KGB's Dept X - which will subsequently give him a bionic replacement arm, turn him into a lethal KGB black-ops assassin, and code name him "Winter Soldier".

 

Captain America #6 (vol 5) (June 2005)

 
To counteract bits and pieces of his memory coming back over time, the Soviets put Bucky in suspended animation for a few years every now and then - which also (rather neatly) explains why he hasn't overtaken Steve Rogers in age.
 
"Out of time", which kicked off in Captain America #1 (vol 5) - cover dated January 2015 but actually published in mid-November 2014 - was a rip-roaring roller coaster espionage story which linked both WW2 and the cold war with the present time. Ed Brubaker's gripping narrative combined with the moody and brilliant artwork by Steve Epting and Michael Lark produced a comic book which rivalled the best of the genre in any media.

It all begins with a whole string of increasingly mysterious murders and attacks which all seem to be connected to Cap in one way or another. At the same time, what little evidence is found seems to be pointing to a cold war Soviet assassin of whom nothing is known other than his codename Winter Soldier. As Cap tries to get the bottom of things, he finds himself drifting back in his mind more and more to the days of WW2, and his memories reveal that Bucky played his part in killing enemy soldiers during their battlefront fights.

 

Captain America #6 (vol 5) (June 2005)
  The real crunch came in Captain America #6, which went on sale in late May 2005. The fabled KGB assassin is revealed to be man a with rather long brown hair, with a bionic arm sporting a Soviet red star on it, and wearing a classic (by comic book standards) black domino face mask. But the real revelation is the realization amongst those trying to unravel the mysterious killings - not the least Cap himself - that they are, in fact, facing... Bucky Barnes.

As a general rule, re-inventing fiction's icons doesn't work, and there are many good reasons why not, but most importantly it has to do with the pivotal role a fictional character plays with regard to how a story builds up and unfolds. It flies in the face of creativity to a certain extent, but the truism that a novel without Hercule Poirot is simply not a Hercule Poirot novel also kicks in when a character appears in said novel who goes by the name of Hercule Poirot but is too far removed from what readers know (and want) the Belgian detective to be.

The history of comic books has an especially rich legacy of unsuccessful attempts at changing central characters, so the odds were clearly stacked against Brubaker. However, albeit amongst some trepidation at Marvel, it soon became clear that the Winter Soldier was a total success. To some extent Brubaker probably profited from the fact that Bucky was an underused persona of the Marvel Universe, but in order to really succeed he had to come up with some very convincing imagineering, and turning a former sidekick into a ruthless pawn of the enemy was just the ticket.

 
Captain America #6 was in such demand that it went to a second printing (although admittedly the original print run of 46.360 wasn't huge by any standards), and sales remained high for the following issues. Marvel loved it, and so did the fans. In the end, the transformation from cliché teen Bucky to gritty adult Winter Soldier was handled so well that the Marvel Universe gained a new character who not only was here to stay but also reinforced the personal drama of Steve Rogers who now found himself in a dark spot not because of Bucky’s death but rather because of the life his former sidekick had been forced to live.

The gripping saga unfolded into an ever bigger picture: in true spy-fi fashion Cap uses the Cosmic Cube, a magical device, to restore Bucky's original identity and memories, which brings the Winter Soldier back into the fold of the good guys - however, Bucky still remembers everything he ever did under Soviet control, so now both he and Cap have their personal pain and mental damage to confront. Different yet now so alike, Barnes - albeit reluctantly - takes up the shield when Steve Rogers is killed, becoming the new Captain America. And once again, this transition - which has been tried more times than fans care to remember with Batman - worked against all odds. Brubaker had instilled a characterization into Bucky Barnes which seemingly could hold just about anything together.

Although many fans actually hoped that Steve Rogers would stay dead, he of course had to come back any way you turned it, the way comic book conventions (not to even mention movie franchises) work, ultimately to become Captain America once more. This also had the added bonus, in this case, of freeing up the Winter Soldier character again, whom Brubaker took on his own adventures, paired with the Black Widow - another victim of Soviet brainwashing and KGB manipulations - on 1 February 2012 (cover dated April 2012) in his own book, Winter Soldier - all set against the backdrop of growing public and political accusations against Bucky Barnes regarding his former crimes (culminating in his going on trial) which can only be stopped by having SHIELD fake his death and stage a funeral.

 

 
 
 

WINTER SOLDIER #1
(April 2012)

"Longest Winter" (pt 1 of 5)
20 pages

Story - Ed Brubaker
Art - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Inks - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Colours - Bettie Breitweiser
Cover - Lee Bermejo

 
The starting point for Winter Soldier, advertised and published by Marvel as a continuous monthly comic book title is summed up on the title splash page of issue #1:
 

Captain America's sidekick James "Bucky" Barnes died in action in the closing days of World War 2, only to be ressurrected by Department X, the Soviet Union's secret science division and brainwashed to be their perfect cold war assassin - the Winter Soldier!

But when his former partner saved him and restored his memories, his troubles truly began...

Now believed dead by the world at large, and haunted by his past, Bucky Barnes fights for redemption as the...

 
 
In this debut issue, Bucky Barnes and Natasha Romanova try to track down three Soviet soldiers from Project Zephyr. Trained by the Winter Soldier himself back when he was under KGB control, they have been forgotten for decades and lying dormant in stasis tube - suntil now. Someone has seemingly activated them, and the Winter Soldier and the Black Widow are sent out to bring them in. Clues gained from a raid of a Las Vegas casino lead them to storehouse somewhere in Minnesota, run by the super militant group known as R.A.I.D.

Brubaker takes the reader straight into the centre of the action of an unfolding saga of international intrigue and global threats which hark back to the cold war - just the right setting for both the Black Widow and the Winter Soldier. Artist Jackson "Butch" Guice delivers the dynamic artwork necessary to get this fast paced story on its way, and by pulling pretty much all the stops (from intricate full page compositions to multidimensional panel composition) it all takes off at rocket speed - so much so that Brubaker and Guice even get away with having a genetically mutated Gorilla (who speaks Russian and wields a machine gun) guard the warehouse.

 

Winter Soldier #1 (April 2012), page 12 - original artwork by Jackson "Butch" Guice (left, personal collection) and published page (right)

 

"In many ways, "Winter Soldier" #1 picks up right where the previous volume of "Captain America" left off. Brubaker and his artistic collaborators know these characters so well, they don’t miss a beat. There’s a noticable shift from the bright and shiny blockbuster action of superhero comics to the shadowy world of espionage, but fans of the Brubaker-invigorated Bucky Barnes will no doubt love this. Finally, the Winter Soldier has his own series, and it’s everything you’d hope for." (cbr.com, Winter Soldier #1 review, February 2012)

 
Winter Soldier #1 did comparatively well, being launched with three variant covers and going to a second printing. Overall, it sold an estimated 53.200 copies and ended up in 349th place on the list of 2012's best-selling comic books in the US (which was topped by the centenary issue of Walking Dead with an estimated 353.200 copies sold, according to comichron.com).
 

WINTER SOLDIER #2
(April 2012)

"Longest Winter" (pt 2 of 5)
20 pages

 

Story - Ed Brubaker
Art - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Inks - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Colours - Bettie Breitweiser
Cover - Lee Bermejo

 
 
 

 
One very neat feature of the monthly issues was a "recap page" which laid out the salient points of the story so far and thus brought latecomers up to speed - an aspect many monthly comic books have simply ignored for years by being totally focused on the subsequent publishing format of a collected trade paperback edition. Included was a nice vignette of artwork from the previous issue which set the tone and mood, plus the creator credits and indicia.
 

"I think I've just always been fascinated at the idea of spies. It's the world's second-oldest profession, and it's about pretending and lying, and finding out secrets. That's the stuff that so much good fiction is made of.  On my personal side, though, I think I'm drawn to it partly because my dad and my uncle were both in the business, in Naval Intel and the CIA. So I grew up with my dad pointing out the incorrect parts of spy movies to me, before I even knew what he did for a living." (Ed Brubaker in Slayton, 2014)

 
Following the usual peak of any first issue, Winter Soldier #2 - launched the same month as issue #1 - did go to a second printing but overall sales were down from 53.200 copies to 43.200 (comichron.com).
 
 

WINTER SOLDIER #3
(May 2012)

"Longest Winter" (pt 3 of 5)
20 pages

 

Story - Ed Brubaker
Art - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Inks -
Stefano Gaudiano, Brian Thies, Jackson "Butch" Guice
Colours - Bettie Breitweiser, Jordie Bellaire
Cover - Lee Bermejo

 
 

 

 
The story continues at a high pace and the creative team (who all at one point previously all worked together on Brubaker's highly successful Captain America run) continue to be in command, pushing a dark and gritty espionage story into what seems like an entire maze of twists and turns - including possibly rethinking the position of well established villains such as Doctor Doom.

The swift storytelling is transformed into images which reek of dynamic action and are dipped in dark shadows courtesy of the pencils of Jackson "Butch" Guice and the inks of Stefano Gaudiano, Brian Thies and Guice.

 

Winter Soldier #3 (May 2012), page 18 - original pencils by Jackson "Butch" Guice (left, personal collection) and published page (right)

 
Jackson "Butch" Guice (*1961) broke into the big publishing names comics industry with Marvel's highly successful toy spin-off title Micronauts, which he pencilled from issue #1 (January 1979) up until issue #58 (May 1984). His prolific and varied work includes the 1984 Marvel Comics adaptation of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, X-Factor and The New Mutants (1986), Iron Man (1988), Doctor Strange, Sorcerer Supreme (1989), Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. (1991) and Iron Man (2007) for Marvel, and post-Crisis Flash (1988), Action Comics (1992-1995, including the "Death of Superman" storyline) and other titles for DC. His work for independent companies includes Ruse at CrossGen (2000-2004). Butch Guice joined the Captain America creative team in 2008 as inker for issues #32-34 before taking on the full artwork for issues #35-48, #600 (as the title reverted to its original numbering), #602-610 and then Captain America Reborn #1-6 (2009-2010).
 
In spite of the artistic quality presented in its pages, Winter Soldier was slipping in the sales department - the number of copies sold for issue #3 was down from 43.200 for the previous issue to 36.700 (comichron.com).
 
 

WINTER SOLDIER #4
(June 2012)

"Longest Winter" (pt 4 of 5)
20 pages

 

Story - Ed Brubaker
Art - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Inks -
Stefano Gaudiano, Jackson "Butch" Guice, Brian Thies
Colours - Bettie Breitweiser, Matthew Wilson
Cover - Lee Bermejo

 
 
 

 

"I love reading about Cold War spy stuff (...) and when I found out the KGB had a science division called Dept. X, I just knew I had to use it, and that it had to be important to the Red Room program and the Winter Soldier." (Ed Brubaker in Slayton, 2014)

 
The sales figures for Winter Soldier #4 didn't fall in line with the exciting espionage yarn heating up and followed the previous downward trend, from 36.700 (Winter Soldier #3) to 34.300 copies sold for this issue (comichron.com). No second print run was required this time, and there was one variant cover on sale.
 

WINTER SOLDIER #5
(July 2012)

"Longest Winter" (pt 5 of 5)
20 pages

 

Story - Ed Brubaker
Art - Jackson "Butch" Guice
Inks -
Stefano Gaudiano, Tom Palmer, Jackson "Butch" Guice
Colours - Bettie Breitweiser
Cover - Lee Bermejo

 
 
 

 
The first story arc of Winter Soldier ends (and heads on into the next arc) as the Winter Soldier and the Black Widow join forces Doctor Doom and take out (and kill) the Red Ghost and his genetically mutated killer apes as well his sleeper agent. The badly wounded former Latverian prime minister is held for interrogation, making this covert black ops mission a success. However, one of the awoken sleepers is still unaccounted for...
 

 
On sale 16 May 2012, this issue had neither a second print run nor any variant covers, as the number of copies sold kept decreasing gradually with each issue - whilst Winter Soldier #4 had sold 34.300 copies, this figure was down to 30.800 for Winter Soldier #5 (comichron.com).
 

 

 
 
BIBLIOGRAPHY

LEE Stan (1974) Origins of Marvel Comics, Simon and Schuster

ROBB Brian J. (2014) A Brief History of Superheroes, Constable & Robinson

SLAYTON Nicholas (2014) "Why Captain America started spying", in The Atlantic, April 8 2014

 



(c) 2016-2017

uploaded to the web 2 January 2017